soldiers (PTSD/suicide) is a public health crisis not a private matter

Michael Robert McNeil

Soldiers Suicide

PTSD is a public health issue, but for some reason our government doesn’t think so. Apparently soldiers and PTSD is a private matter that is even deemed ” an administrative issue,” as was stated by one soldier in her statement to the press. Certainly cutting Veteran Affairs Canada’s services is a colossal step in the wrong direction and so is the lack of education on what exactly post traumatic stress disorder is and how it manifests after war.  Further to this, PTSD is complicated and requires special knowledge and training by professionals that treat it. Unfortunately many PTSD treatments are designed to be sold to the consumer in manualized  treatment packages with 12 sessions or more, failing to recognize that trauma and the brain is complex and cannot be fixed in a set amount of time. Such manualized programs are designed for research purposes to measure outcomes and were actually never meant to be used as a measurement (time frame) for healing.

Any therapist will tell you that substances are often used by people as a way to change state, calm the nervous system, and shut the mind down to get away from flash backs, nightmares, and racing thoughts. Therefore, treatment is unique to each individual and cannot be measured in neat and tidy sessions designed for the middle class without a substance abuse concern.  It is these very manualized programs that the government uses to measure outcomes and then decides what kind of financial resources should be distributed to certain mental health organizations. Such programs are designed to move soldiers on quickly to support  fiscal prudence. It is beyond my understanding how one can negotiate funds in such a way where soldiers are time limited help. Such practice further perpetuates the myth that PTSD is a private matter and not a public one

If only a soldier or sexual abuse survivor could be healed in 12 sessions or more!

PTSD is complicated. A trigger in the present that is connected to an event in a war can also be connected to feeder memories connected to childhood or a past adult  trauma. Every person is different with a unique history, and sense of self-worth.  Each person has unique circumstances. When we look at healing trauma we look at cultural negotiations, substance abuse, the culture of the person’s occupation,  family background, biology, and social supports.

To suggest in this video then, that PTSD was not the cause of these  soldiers suicide’s is irresponsible.  A soldier returning to his or her homeland has many things to negotiate while dealing with debilitating and distressing symptoms that are enough to take any one out. If suicide is complex, which I think everyone understands,  then I guess we can close the door to this one and quietly speak about the tragedy as just that, a tragedy. But what if you  are wrong?  What if when one begins to look at the research with PTSD,  one realizes that suicide is a factor and a common outcome of untreated severe PTSD symptoms?  What if in suggesting that suicide in this case is complicated, and not necessarily a result of  soldiers PTSD symptoms,  you are actually maintaining a complicity to the matter of soldiers and suicide. In that complicity of ” It’s complicated,” are you not maintaining this matter remain a private one?

Lets please pay attention to these soldiers suicide’s  and not undermine the severity of this very important public health crisis we have on our hands!!

Canada you can do better.

One thought on “soldiers (PTSD/suicide) is a public health crisis not a private matter

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s